Quick Answer: How does handling-related damage affect scrap and rework in manufacturing?
Mishandling parts increases the risk of several types of damage, from scuffed finishes and dented housings to cracked or broken components. Some affected items can be saved through rework, others must be scrapped, and many are returned by unhappy purchasers. Crucially, mishandling is not inevitable in manufacturing, as industrial manipulators are designed to grip, move, and release items with speed, efficiency, and a greatly reduced risk of damage.
The Hidden Cost of Manual Handling
Manufacturing plants typically track defects and downtime caused by their machines. Whether from mechanical failures, incorrect setups, or other reasons, these issues can have a significant negative financial impact on a business, so documenting them is essential.
Manufacturers tend to be less focused on the impact manual material handling has on product integrity. If incidents are noted at all, they are commonly lumped in with machine-related production problems.
To accurately calculate the financial expense of handling-related damage, companies must categorize and collect data on it separately. Perhaps more importantly, proper categorization is vital for determining and dealing with causes. Replacing a worn or damaged part within a manufacturing system is important, but if the workers loading or unloading parts from the system or removing parts from the system continue to make handling mistakes, product integrity and the company’s profitability will continue to suffer.
Manufacturers must also see the big picture and measure the full impact when it comes to manual handling. This includes the costs of materials in scrapped items and the value of the wasted labor and machine cycles for both scrapped and reworked parts.
Where and How Handling Damage Occurs on the Floor
Product damage from handling mistakes can happen anywhere in a manufacturing environment where manual manipulation takes place. However, certain areas are more prone to miscues.
For example, drops and accidental collisions are more common in tight spaces. Operators trying to navigate complex layouts or confined spaces are constantly evaluating their clearances as they lift, turn, step, and place items. Unsurprisingly, it is easy to be distracted in one way or another in these environments and drop an item, bang it into part of the production line infrastructure, or otherwise damage it.
The same is true when manually handling heavy, oversized, or awkwardly shaped components, even in more spacious surroundings. Workers instinctively prioritize their balance (and their safety) over the gentle lifting and placement of these items. One small slip on a slick patch of flooring or trip over a floor mat, and a part that should have been placed with minimal impact instead hits its spot with excessive force.
Even items that are lifted and placed gently can be damaged if they are stacked unevenly. The growing stress as each additional item is placed can create micro-cracks or abrasions that immediately affect an item’s appearance and can adversely affect its physical integrity as the stresses intensify.
The Role of Operator Fatigue and Technique Variation in Handling-Related Damage
In many cases, handling-related product damage isn’t the result of an accident but rather a gradual decrease in precision as an operator becomes increasingly fatigued throughout their shift. When a worker’s fatigue becomes intense, the risk of dropped items increases dramatically.
Beyond the physical effects of fatigue, team members tend to unintentionally lower their quality standards as they get later in their shift. A condition that was unacceptable when they started working becomes “good enough” later. Whether that means seating a part in a receptacle a little askew or the alignment of stacked items progressively deviating over time, the result can be damage that causes scrap or rework.
Delayed Reaction: When Damage Is Exposed by a Quality Inspection
Damage caused by poor handling can waste more time than just what was spent at the station in question. If an item continues down the production line through several more operations before being caught in a quality inspection and scrapped, all of the subsequent work is lost, and the cost of it adds to the overall cost of parts produced or subtracts from overall revenue — depending on how you choose to view it.
Even damage that can be reworked hurts profitability, not to mention stressing managers trying to reach quotas or meet delivery deadlines. It can also create a ripple effect, delaying work on other jobs and putting their timelines at risk.
Removing Variability With Industrial Manipulators
One of the most challenging aspects of addressing damage from manual handling in manufacturing is that there is a high degree of variability. One operator might have difficulty due to the weight of a particular part, while another might struggle because of its awkward shape, and yet another has significant fatigue issues late in their shift.
Industrial manipulators take most or all of the variability out of the equation. Because a Dalmec lift-assist device is built to address a specific task, it never struggles with it. Customized end effectors (grippers) provide a secure hold without inflicting excessive pressure, and the unit’s lifting mechanism can easily handle an item’s weight.
Each gripping, lifting, and moving operation is performed with the same degree of precision. Industrial manipulators essentially make payloads “weightless” from the operator’s perspective, enabling them to lift and move items smoothly, with no sudden jerks, uncontrolled releases, or other actions that endanger the part being manipulated or create a safety risk for the employee.
Empowering Your Operators, Not Replacing Them
Many manufacturers assume the only way to eliminate handling damage is to take humans out of the equation through full automation. However, robots aren’t always practical, especially when visual inspections are needed before placement. Industrial manipulators offer a best-of-both-worlds alternative. They aren’t robots designed to replace your workforce. Instead, they are systems engineered to assist workers by neutralizing the physical burden of heavy, awkward loads.
When an operator uses an industrial manipulator, the machine delivers the power, but the human operator provides the judgment. A worker who doesn’t have to strain to support an item’s weight can concentrate on getting the part exactly where it needs to go. They guide the component into place, avoiding the sudden drops, forceful adjustments, and unintended collisions that happen when a worker is overwhelmed by an item’s physical characteristics, their own fatigue, or both.
Final Thoughts
Reducing or eliminating handling-related damage by implementing industrial manipulators benefits your business, employees, and customers in many ways. If you have general questions about our systems or specific questions about your environment, our experts are happy to answer them. Contact Dalmec today.